Due
to property or cash donations from IHT donors, IHT can sell a house that might
be valued at $375,000 to qualified buyers for between $165,000 and $195,000. In
order to ensure that the significant investment made by IHT’s donors remains
available to future purchasers of the properties, IHT holds affordability
covenants which run with the deeds on the houses. Within the affordability
covenants is the “Resale Price” worksheet. The worksheet contains two formulas
which determine the resale price of a house. The lower of the two numbers is
the price at which the owner can sell the house.
The
objective of the formulas is to keep the properties permanently available to
MDI’s working individuals and families by means of a shared equity formula. The
first and each successive property owner at Ripples Hill has the opportunity to
earn a limited amount of equity from their house at resale, while at the same
time keeping the house affordable to future buyers with similar household
income.
The Maximum Resale Price (MRP)
The
first formula is the Maximum Resale Price (MRP). The basic multiplier for
determining the MRP is the change in median wages over the period of time that
the homeowner owns the house. For example, if that cumulative change is 20%
over ten years of ownership, then the multiplying factor is 1.2 (or 120%).
Using that 1.2 factor, a base house built/purchased for $150,000 is valued at
$180,000 under the formula ($150,000 X 1.2) ten years after purchase. The
formula also uses the change in median wages to value improvements (over and
above normal maintenance) added into the MRP.
The Maximum Affordable Cost (MAC)
The
MRP calculations are then measured against the Maximum Affordable Cost (MAC) of
the house at the time of resale. The MAC multiplies the prevailing annual
median household income (AMI) for a family of four or fewer at a predetermined
percentage of AMI by 2.5. The houses (continued on reverse side)at Ripples Hill are intended for individuals and
families at 120% AMI, so IHT uses 120% in the Ripples Hill MAC formula. Houses
affordable to people above 120% AMI, such as the houses at Sabah Woods, use
higher percentages in their formulas. The percentage of AMI in each formula is
the income level appropriate to people who can afford that particular home. The
2.5 stems from the opinions of many financial experts who believe households
should not spend more than 2.5 times their household income to purchase a
residential property. Thus, if a family’s income was $70,000, then that family
could afford 2.5 X $70,000, or $175,000, on a
house if they made (100%) median income. The median income levels in IHT’s
formula range from 120%-180% and match the income levels of MDI’s workforce who
can secure bank financing to purchase a house, but still cannot afford a market
rate house on the island.
If
the house in the above example was initially purchased at 120% AMI and the owner
decided to sell it, the MAC calculation would be 120% X ($70,000 X 2.5), or 1.2
X $175,000, or $210,000. This calculation would be compared to the MRP and the
lower of the two would be used.
Protecting the Initial Investment and the Future Buyer
A number of
folks have suggested that the limited equity approach is not for them because
they want no strings attached when they go to sell their house. We understand
that desire but also know that if it were possible for moderate income families
to buy affordable land or houses on MDI, Island Housing Trust wouldn’t need to
exist! We also know that the many seasonal and year-round residents who have
invested in IHT’s work would not continue to do that if we provided housing
opportunities to year-round workers who could “flip” the properties for a
substantial windfall within months or years of purchasing them rather than have
them remain the permanent stock of affordable year-round housing. Thus, the
need for affordability covenants.
Christopher Spruce, Executive Director • Island Housing Trust • P.O. Box 851 • Mount Desert, ME 04660
207-288-4496 (office) • director@islandhousingtrust.org
Office located at: 8-B Bethany Lane, West Eden Common, Bar Harbor, ME 04609